ACCA AAA December 2026: Why Written Representations Score Zero on Provisions and Impairment Evidence

Richard Clarke

In AAA, "obtain a written representation" and "agree to bank statements" are the two evidence points examiners keep scoring at zero on provisions and impairment. The marks go to evidence that tests management's assumptions, not evidence that just confirms a number exists.

What the examiner keeps saying

The Sep/Dec 2025 AAA examiner's report is blunt about the Mistral question. Candidates were asked for evidence on development costs and an impairment review, and many proposed agreeing the $550 million spend to bank statements – something the examiner pointed out "would not be possible". Reviewing board minutes and getting written representations were also flagged as weak for a recognition issue. What scored? Agreeing costs to invoices or employee timesheets and testing the project against the IAS 38 capitalisation criteria.

The same report noted that "very few candidates" considered how the impairment review would actually be performed. The best answers spotted that with all sales of the product suspended, value in use would be severely diminished – and built their evidence around that. On the Kerr warranty provision, a representation that the provision was complete earned nothing. Credit went to candidates who challenged how the warranty assumptions had been set.

This isn't new. In the Mar/Jun 2023 report (Slaindar), weaker candidates answered an estimates requirement by listing generic substantive procedures. The good answers weren't "approaching the requirement from a substantive audit procedures angle" at all – they were challenging the assumptions behind the estimate. That is ISA 540 (Revised) in one sentence: the risk sits in the method, the data and the assumptions, so that's where your evidence must go.

And on provisions specifically, the examiner keeps seeing the IAS 37 trap. In Mistral, it could not be determined whether a payment was probable or how much it would be – yet most answers jumped straight to "the provision is understated". Back in Dec 2019 the report said the same thing: many candidates wanted to provide for a contingent liability that was only possible.

Worked example: wrong vs right

Scenario: A client faces a customer lawsuit. Management has disclosed a contingent liability but recognised no provision. Lawyers' correspondence is "cautiously optimistic". Materiality is $400,000; the claim is $2.1 million.

Weak answer (scores around 1 mark): "The provision may be understated. Obtain a written representation from management that the claim will not succeed. Discuss with the directors. Review board minutes."

Strong answer (scores the marks): "The claim is material at 5.3 times materiality. Under IAS 37, a provision is only required if an outflow is probable and can be reliably estimated – 'cautiously optimistic' suggests possible, not probable, so disclosure may be appropriate. The risk is management bias towards non-recognition. Evidence: a written confirmation direct from the client's lawyers on the likely outcome and estimated settlement range; review of correspondence with the claimant for any settlement offers; review of post year-end cash book and legal invoices for payments or escalating costs; comparison with outcomes of similar past claims to assess management's track record on estimates. A written representation is supporting evidence only and cannot replace the legal confirmation."

Same scenario. The second answer quantifies, applies the accounting rule, identifies the bias risk, and names evidence that could actually change the conclusion.

What to do

1. Ask "could this evidence prove management wrong?" If the answer is no – representations, board minutes, "discuss with management" – it's not your main evidence point. Lead with third-party, external or recalculated evidence.

2. Attack the assumption, not the number. For every estimate, name the one assumption that drives it (discount rate, growth forecast, claim success rate, warranty return rate) and give a specific test for it: compare to market data, past accuracy, post year-end events.

3. Get the accounting decision right before you write evidence. Probable vs possible, value in use vs fair value less costs of disposal, capitalise vs expense. If your accounting conclusion is wrong, your evidence list is aimed at the wrong target.

The bottom line

AAA pass rates typically sit around 40% – fewer than half of candidates get through – and evidence requirements on estimates, provisions and impairment turn up sitting after sitting in Section A and B. The examiner has said it repeatedly: generic answers that don't build on the scenario gain little to no credit.

Representations confirm what management believes. Your job is to find out whether they're right.