ACCA SBR December 2026: Sold Shares but Kept Control? Why There's No Gain in Profit or Loss

Richard Clarke

Selling shares in a subsidiary but keeping control is not a disposal. There is no gain or loss in profit or loss, goodwill doesn't move, and the difference between the cash received and the increase in NCI goes straight to equity.

What the examiner saw in June 2026

Question 1 of the June 2026 SBR exam (Shibe Co) gave candidates 7 marks for a sale of shares in a subsidiary, Borr, where control was retained. It should have been easy marks. It wasn't.

The examiner's report is blunt. Weaker answers calculated a gain or loss on disposal and put it through profit or loss. Very few candidates stated that goodwill stays exactly the same. And many couldn't produce the increase in non-controlling interest because they never worked out Borr's net assets at the transfer date, or they left out goodwill and the depreciated fair value adjustments.

Then the damage spread. Part (c) asked candidates to correct a pre-populated group statement of financial position, and few carried their part (b) adjustment into it. One misunderstanding cost marks in two places.

Why there's no gain: the IFRS 10 logic

IFRS 10 treats a change in ownership that doesn't lose control as a transaction between owners acting in their capacity as owners. The group hasn't sold anything. It still controls 100% of the subsidiary's assets and liabilities, so nothing is derecognised. All that has changed is how the group's equity is split between parent shareholders and the NCI.

Transactions with owners never go through profit or loss. That's the whole answer, and it is the sentence that earns the explanation marks most candidates skip.

Compare loss of control (say 80% down to 30%). That is a genuine disposal: you derecognise the subsidiary's net assets, goodwill and NCI, remeasure the retained stake to fair value, and a gain or loss hits profit or loss. Know which side of the control line you are on before you write a single number.

Worked example: wrong vs right

Parent owns 80% of Sub and sells 20% for $30m cash, keeping 60% (still control). At the date of sale:

Sub's net assets in its own books: $85m
Fair value adjustment at acquisition of $20m, less $5m depreciated since: $15m remaining
Goodwill (NCI at fair value, full method): $20m

The wrong answer: "Profit on disposal = $30m – (20% × $85m) = $13m, recognised in profit or loss. Derecognise 20% of goodwill." Three errors: the gain shouldn't exist, the net assets ignore the fair value adjustment, and goodwill shouldn't be touched.

The right answer:

Net assets for the group = $85m + $15m = $100m
Add goodwill (full method) = $20m, total $120m
Increase in NCI = 20% × $120m = $24m
Cash received = $30m
Difference = $30m – $24m = $6m credited to parent's equity

Journal: Dr Cash $30m, Cr NCI $24m, Cr Equity (attributable to parent) $6m. Goodwill stays at $20m. Profit or loss: nil.

If NCI was measured at its proportionate share of net assets, no goodwill belongs to the NCI, so the increase is simply 20% × $100m = $20m, and $10m goes to equity. Read the scenario to find which method was used.

The same logic runs in reverse when the parent buys more shares in a subsidiary it already controls: NCI decreases, and the difference between the cash paid and the NCI decrease is adjusted in parent's equity. Still no profit or loss, still no change to goodwill.

What to do

1. Write the control test first. One line: "Parent retains control (80% to 60%), so under IFRS 10 this is a transaction with owners. No gain or loss is recognised and goodwill is not remeasured." That line alone picks up marks the June candidates missed.

2. Rebuild net assets at the transaction date. Book net assets plus the fair value adjustment net of depreciation to date, plus goodwill if NCI was at fair value. Never use the acquisition-date figure or the subsidiary's own books unadjusted.

3. Carry your adjustment through. If a later part asks for a corrected group SOFP, put the NCI increase and the equity adjustment into it and make sure goodwill is unchanged. Check your units too: the J26 examiner flagged workings in $000 against a draft in $m.

The bottom line

Roughly half of SBR candidates pass each sitting, and Question 1 group accounting is where many fall short, often by burning time on calculations and leaving Question 3 under-attempted. This one is 7 marks of logic, not arithmetic. Sold shares but kept control? Equity, not profit.