Market failure - externalities 5 / 9

Market failure - externalities

Externalities

A positive or negative impact of a transaction on people who are external to that transaction (ie not a buyer or seller).

Positive and negative externalities

  • Positive externalities

    Benefits from production or consumption of a good or service that extend beyond the trading parties (ie the buyer and seller)

  • Negative externalities

    Costs from production or consumption of a good or service that extend beyond those paid for by the trading parties

Merit and demerit goods

Sometimes a product generates such a high impact in terms of externalities that it is generally agreed that this product is either good or bad for society as a whole.

  • Merit good

    Generates positive externalities to society as a whole (social benefits). 

    For example, vaccinations, education

  • Demerit good

    Generates negative externalities to society as a whole (social costs). 

    For example, smoking.

Dealing with externalities

Merit goodsDemerit goods
Subsidies to reduce the price. Indirect taxation to raise price.
Public information campaign to stress benefits. Public information campaign to raise awareness of risks.
Public provision of the product. Legislation/ ban on product, eg smoking in public buildings.
Price regulation (maximum price). Price regulation (minimum price).

Public goods

Public goods have two characteristics:

  1. Non-diminishability

    -the good or service can serve a small or large number of people at exactly the same cost

    E.g. the good or service does not diminish in supply as more people enjoy it.

  2. Non-exclusivity

    - providers of the good or service cannot exclude non-payers, which makes it unlikely that it will be provided by profit-seeking providers.

Note that not all goods provided by the public sector are public goods,

e.g.
healthcare is a merit good, not a public good, because it is diminishable (ie there is less healthcare available for others as more people use healthcare resources).