ACCA FM December 2026: Business Valuation — Why Your DVM and Loan Note Values Are Wrong
Most FM business valuation marks are lost on three inputs: the wrong earnings figure in P/E, the wrong dividend in the dividend valuation model (DVM), and the wrong discount rate for loan notes. Your method is probably fine. The numbers you feed into it are what cost you.
What the examiner saw in the latest FM report
The March/June 2026 FM examiner's report goes through a Section B valuation question (Orla Co) line by line. The pattern is clear. Candidates knew the formulas, then put the wrong numbers into them.
P/E valuation. The correct answer was $756m, which is the P/E ratio multiplied by profit for the year. Some candidates used retained profit ($35m) instead, which undervalues the company badly. Others multiplied by 1.04 to "grow" the earnings and got $786m. The P/E method uses current earnings. You don't apply growth in it.
Dividend valuation model. The correct answer was $637m: $49m × 1.04 / (0.12 − 0.04). The most common error was putting d0 on top instead of d1. Some candidates left growth out entirely.
Loan notes. The correct market value was $100.44 per $100 nominal, or $120.5m in total. Candidates ignored the 5% redemption premium, or discounted at the 6% coupon rate rather than the 7% pre-tax cost of debt. The coupon tells you the cash flow. It never tells you the discount rate.
The same report flags two related Section A slips: using a cum-div preference share price instead of the ex-div price, and deducting tax from the cost of preference shares. Preference dividends are not tax-deductible, so kp = d / P0 (ex-div), with no tax adjustment.
Worked example: wrong vs right
DVM. Dividend just paid $49m, growth 4%, cost of equity 12%.
Wrong: $49m / (0.12 − 0.04) = $612.5m. That's d0 on top, so the answer is understated by $24.5m.
Right: $49m × 1.04 = $50.96m. Then $50.96m / 0.08 = $637m.
Loan notes. 6% coupon, redeemable at a 5% premium in four years, pre-tax cost of debt 7%.
Wrong (discount at the coupon rate): (6 × 3.465) + (105 × 0.792) = $103.95.
Wrong (ignore the premium): (6 × 3.387) + (100 × 0.763) = $96.62.
Right: (6 × 3.387) + (105 × 0.763) = $100.44 per $100 nominal.
The cash flows are pre-tax interest and the redemption value, because you are valuing the instrument from the investor's side. Tax relief on interest belongs in the company's cost of debt for WACC, not in the market value.
Don't skip the theory marks
The same sitting tested market efficiency in Section A, and most candidates got it wrong. Weak-form efficiency says nothing about how fast prices react to news. Under strong-form efficiency, insiders can't make abnormal gains either. Noise traders also caught people out: they follow trends and overreact, so "rational" and "well-timed" were the wrong choices. These questions are quick marks if you know the definitions precisely, and lost marks if you only half know them.
What to do this week
1. Write the input before the formula. Before every valuation, write one line naming your input, e.g. "Earnings = profit for the year $X" or "d1 = d0 × (1 + g)". It takes ten seconds and blocks the most common errors.
2. Draw a loan note timeline every time. Put interest in years 1 to n and the redemption value (including any premium) in year n, then discount at the investor's required return. If the coupon rate and the discount rate are the same in your workings, stop and check.
3. Drill ex-div prices and EMH definitions. Do ten Section A valuation and efficiency OTs, and for each one say out loud whether the price is cum-div or ex-div. These are 2-mark questions with no calculation, so they're the cheapest marks on the paper.
The numbers
FM pass rates were 48% in June 2026 and 47% in September 2026, so more than half of candidates fail. Business valuation shows up across Sections A, B and C, and the same input errors repeat in every sitting.
The formula gets you nothing if the number going into it is wrong, so check your inputs first.